EastBay said:
Should I get a dedicated start for #1 and a deep cycle for #2.
Thank you.
Eastpoint
You pretty much nailed it right there except the numbers. Get a battery rated marine Deepcycle/starting, the biggest one that will fit and wire it to #1. Get a second "Marine Cranking" battery and wire it to #2. For the cranking, go at least 650 CCA if you are weight conscious, bigger if it makes you feel better.
On a morning start throw the switch to both, crank that mother up, make sure the voltage comes up and leave it on both until your first (or second or whatever) stop. After that switch to #1 and leave it there the rest of the day/night unless you have cranking issues. If you do have issues, switch to #2, if that don't work, switch to both.
Do not worry about switching to any positions except OFF with the engine running. All other positions have at least 1 battery connected (make before break) and will not damage your engine electronics or alternator. Going to OFF while running can damage stuff.
I'm definitely a fan of Optima batteries, but they are pricey. If I had to pick one of the above I would get an Optima cranking battery and a whatever deepcycle. I have 4 reasons for this recommendation, first the Optima Deepcycle has less amp hours than most for the same size/weight. Second, I find the Optima's hold a charge for much longer than a normal wet battery. Third, let a normal cranking battery go full dead and it's time for a new one, deepcycle batteries are made to come back from the dead. Fourth, The Optima will last at least 2 of the deepcycles using this scheme.