Yah, understand, anything over 74" prop is starting to push it, 76" hard max for sure. The engine probably makes 250-300 Hp at best at 5,500 RPM unless it has been worked. 2,750 prop speed with 2:1 or 2,400 at 2.3:1.
The 2:1 works and there are props that will work well without changing the rigging, but the 2.3 with larger 78-80" blades will give you more push (5-10%??). You should talk with the prop manufacturers about 74-76" options on the 2.3, unfortunately the selection is limited without buying a cut down version of a larger blade.
If you have any thoughts of upgrading the engine going forward, then the 2.3 and room for 80" of prop is the place to start. Note that you can always add blocks to raise the rigging and weld in horizontal sections to make it wider vs. starting over.