Norris,
I believe you are missing the bigger picture when you look at the weight distibution first and the engine attitude (angle) second.
First of all we have to assume there are no problems with the hull that will keep it from running as it should. Remeber that in both cases, (engine attitude and weight) you are talking about fine tuning. Ie. If something is way out of whack, neither is going to solve the problem.
Norris said:
. . . whenever a boat is porpoising folks talk about lowering the back of the motor to lower the nose, or moving weight forward, like the fuel tank, batteries or a big beer cooler or whatever. BUt no one ever talks about going the other way . . .
There is more than one way to view the answer to your question.
Most obviously and importantly: 1)
if the back of the motor is already to high it will cause the bow to plow, not porpoise . . . and 2)
if there is already to much weight forward it will cause the bow to plow, not propoise. Additionally, while there may be room to move rigging forward if need be, it seldom can moved back because the prop is generally lower than the top of the transom. Hence, the neccessity of moving everything else to adjust weight if need be.
When nearly any boat (airboat, skiboat, sportboat, offshoreboat)
has a straight, true hull and is porposing it is because the attitude of the propulsion system is lifting the bow beyond the capability of the drive system to hold it up there. Then it falls back down, bounces . . . and the process starts over again. If you trim the attitude of the propulsion system down just enough to prevent this porpoising, it will be running at its best attitude possible given the propulsion system being used.
The most obvious example of this would be power trim on an outboard motor or an I/O setup. Porpoise, trim down OR Plow, trim up. With inboard engines and airboats this is not possible so then you have to resort to the infamous "Trim Tab" to accomplish this adjustment as there is no "power trim" system available. :?
Then you end up back where we started . . . . A) staight hull, B) engine attitude, C) weight distribution. :wink:
Hope that all made sense.
Deano